The Deal Guy
10 Things You SHOULD Be Buying at Costco in September 2026
βSomeone was just as inventive and intelligent for creating these new Key lime pie ice cream sandwiches at 14.79.β
Jeni's Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwich 8-Pack (3.5 oz each)
$9.99Real in-store prices from 600+ Costco locations. Download on the App Store to track prices, scan shelf tags, and get alerts.
In-store pricing snapshot
Based on recent checks across 180 Costco warehouses reporting.
* Prices shown are for Costco members only.
Jeni's Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches bring together tropical, tart key lime ice cream and classic graham cracker cookies in a perfectly portioned frozen treat. Each sandwich features Jeni's signature key lime ice cream made with key lime concentrate, key lime puree, and a touch of lime oil for a bright, citrusy punch. The filling is crafted with real cream, nonfat milk, cane sugar, and cultured buttermilk, giving it a rich and creamy texture. The graham cracker cookies are made with unbleached wheat flour, graham flour, molasses, and honey.
This Costco pack includes 8 individually wrapped sandwiches, each weighing 3.5 oz (75g), distributed by Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams, LLC of Columbus, Ohio. Keep frozen.
Nutrition per serving (1 sandwich, 75g): 210 calories, 3g protein, 34g total carbohydrate (2g dietary fiber, 19g total sugars including 16g added sugars), 8g total fat (5g saturated fat, 0g trans fat), 15mg cholesterol, 210mg sodium. Vitamins and minerals: Vitamin D 0mcg, Calcium 50mg, Iron 0mg, Potassium 120mg. Ingredients: Graham cookie (unbleached unenriched wheat flour, graham flour, sugar, palm oil, molasses, honey, salt, sodium bicarbonate), nonfat milk, cream, cane sugar, key lime puree (water, key lime concentrate, pulp cells, lime oil), cultured buttermilk (cultured reduced fat milk, salt, vitamin A palmitate, vitamin D3), yogurt (milk, nonfat milk, cultures), tapioca syrup, citric acid, sunflower lecithin, guar gum, carob bean gum, pumpkin concentrate (color), spirulina concentrate (color), apple concentrate (color), lime oil. Allergens: Contains milk and wheat. Made in a kitchen that also makes products containing milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, and wheat.
Showing the newest creator mentions for this item.
The Deal Guy
10 Things You SHOULD Be Buying at Costco in September 2026
βSomeone was just as inventive and intelligent for creating these new Key lime pie ice cream sandwiches at 14.79.β
The Grocery Lady
What's NEW atβ¨COSTCOβ¨ || New Arrivals at COSTCO
β14.79. Oh my word, the amount of tastiness is, it's a lot.β
Costco's Latest
NEW Costco Finds This Week | Summer Items Are HERE βοΈ Home, Food, Clothes, Games + More Shopping
βthis is Jeni's frozen dessert sandwiches, key lime pie style... I'm gonna guess 12.99.β
Recent price trends and regional spread across Costco warehouses.
Aggregate price checks across warehouses
Lowest
$9.99
Highest
$14.79
Avg change
-$1.62 (-11.2%)
Latest average
$12.87
Regional pricing and availability by warehouse area
Upgrade to view regional prices and availability
Compare warehouse-level prices, local stock status, and regional patterns in Premium Web.
Upgrade to Premium WebUnlock full historical charts, warehouse-level pricing, and regional filters with Warehouse Runner Premium Web.
$79.97
HARDWARE
$2.97
FOOD
$139.97
SMALL APPLIANCES
$79.97
SPORTING GOODS
$199.97
SPORTING GOODS
$9.97
MEDIA
$6.97
MENS APPAREL
$9.97
HARDWARE
Previewing 5 of 180 warehouse prices.
| Warehouse | Price | Status | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|
Mall Of Georgia#366β 1550 Mall of Georgia Blvd Buford, GA 30519-6551 | $14.49 | Low Stock | Sep 20, 2026 |
Gwinnett#187β 3980 Venture Dr Duluth, GA 30096-5077 | $9.99 | Low Stock | Sep 20, 2026 |
Glenview#348β 2900 Patriot Blvd Glenview, IL 60026-8046 | $14.79 | Low Stock | Sep 20, 2026 |
E Jacksonville#357β 4901 Gate Pkwy Jacksonville, FL 32246-4405 | $9.99 | Low Stock | Sep 20, 2026 |
Ankeny#1630β 4000 NE Spectrum Drive Ankeny, IA 50021 | $14.79 | Low Stock | Sep 20, 2026 |